site logo


Some time ago I entered a fairly large library--one of more than

two hundred thousand volumes--to seek the little brochure on Karl

Marx written by his old friend and genial comrade Wilhelm

Liebknecht. It was in the card catalogue. As I made a note of its

number, my friend the librarian came up to me, and I asked him

whether it was not strange that a man like Marx should have so

many books devoted to him, for I had roug
ly reckoned the number

at several hundred.

"Not at all," said he; "and we have here only a feeble nucleus of

the Marx literature--just enough, in fact, to give you a glimpse

of what that literature really is. These are merely the books

written by Marx himself, and the translations of them, with a few

expository monographs. Anything like a real Marx collection would

take up a special room in this library, and would have to have its

own separate catalogue. You see that even these two or three

hundred books contain large volumes of small pamphlets in many

languages--German, English, French, Italian, Russian, Polish,

Yiddish, Swedish, Hungarian, Spanish; and here," he concluded,

pointing to a recently numbered card, "is one in Japanese."

My curiosity was sufficiently excited to look into the matter

somewhat further. I visited another library, which was appreciably

larger, and whose managers were evidently less guided by their

prejudices. Here were several thousand books on Marx, and I spent

the best part of the day in looking them over.

What struck me as most singular was the fact that there was

scarcely a volume about Marx himself. Practically all the books

dealt with his theory of capital and his other socialistic views.

The man himself, his personality, and the facts of his life were

dismissed in the most meager fashion, while his economic theories

were discussed with something that verged upon fury. Even such

standard works as those of Mehring and Spargo, which profess to be

partly biographical, sum up the personal side of Marx in a few

pages. In fact, in the latter's preface he seems conscious of this

defect, and says:

Whether socialism proves, in the long span of centuries, to be

good or evil, a blessing to men or a curse, Karl Marx must always

be an object of interest as one of the great world-figures of

immortal memory. As the years go by, thoughtful men and women will

find the same interest in studying the life and work of Marx that

they do in studying the life and work of Cromwell, of Wesley, or

of Darwin, to name three immortal world-figures of vastly

divergent types.

Singularly little is known of Karl Marx, even by his most ardent

followers. They know his work, having studied his Das Kapital with

the devotion and earnestness with which an older generation of

Christians studied the Bible, but they are very generally

unacquainted with the man himself. Although more than twenty-six

years have elapsed since the death of Marx, there is no adequate

biography of him in any language.

Doubtless some better-equipped German writer, such as Franz

Mehring or Eduard Bernstein, will some day give us the adequate

and full biography for which the world now waits.

Here is an admission that there exists no adequate biography of

Karl Marx, and here is also an intimation that simply as a man,

and not merely as a great firebrand of socialism, Marx is well

worth studying. And so it has occurred to me to give in these

pages one episode of his career that seems to me quite curious,

together with some significant touches concerning the man as apart

from the socialist. Let the thousands of volumes already in

existence suffice for the latter. The motto of this paper is not

the Vergilian "Arms and the man I sing," but simply "The man I

sing"--and the woman. Karl Marx was born nearly ninety-four years

ago--May 5, 1818--in the city which the French call Treves and the

Germans Trier, among the vine-clad hills of the Moselle. Today,

the town is commonplace enough when you pass through it, but when

you look into its history, and seek out that history's evidences,

you will find that it was not always a rather sleepy little place.

It was one of the chosen abodes of the Emperors of the West, after

Rome began to be governed by Gauls and Spaniards, rather than by

Romans and Italians. The traveler often pauses there to see the

Porta Nigra, that immense gate once strongly fortified, and he

will doubtless visit also what is left of the fine baths and


Treves, therefore, has a right to be termed imperial, and it was

the birthplace of one whose sway over the minds of men has been

both imperial and imperious.

Karl Marx was one of those whose intellectual achievements were so

great as to dwarf his individuality and his private life. What he

taught with almost terrific vigor made his very presence in the

Continental monarchies a source of eminent danger. He was driven

from country to country. Kings and emperors were leagued together

against him. Soldiers were called forth, and blood was shed

because of him. But, little by little, his teaching seems to have

leavened the thought of the whole civilized world, so that to-day

thousands who barely know his name are deeply affected by his

ideas, and believe that the state should control and manage

everything for the good of all.

Marx seems to have inherited little from either of his parents.

His father, Heinrich Marx, was a provincial Jewish lawyer who had

adopted Christianity, probably because it was expedient, and

because it enabled him to hold local offices and gain some social

consequence. He had changed his name from Mordecai to Marx.

The elder Marx was very shrewd and tactful, and achieved a fair

position among the professional men and small officials in the

city of Treves. He had seen the horrors of the French Revolution,

and was philosopher enough to understand the meaning of that

mighty upheaval, and of the Napoleonic era which followed.

Napoleon, indeed, had done much to relieve his race from petty

oppression. France made the Jews in every respect the equals of

the Gentiles. One of its ablest marshals--Massena--was a Jew, and

therefore, when the imperial eagle was at the zenith of its

flight, the Jews in every city and town of Europe were

enthusiastic admirers of Napoleon, some even calling him the


Karl Marx's mother, it is certain, endowed him with none of his

gifts. She was a Netherlandish Jewess of the strictly domestic and

conservative type, fond of her children and her home, and

detesting any talk that looked to revolutionary ideas or to a

change in the social order. She became a Christian with her

husband, but the word meant little to her. It was sufficient that

she believed in God; and for this she was teased by some of her

skeptical friends. Replying to them, she uttered the only epigram

that has ever been ascribed to her.

"Yes," she said, "I believe in God, not for God's sake, but for my


She was so little affected by change of scene that to the day of

her death she never mastered German, but spoke almost wholly in

her native Dutch. Had we time, we might dwell upon the unhappy

paradox of her life. In her son Karl she found an especial joy, as

did her husband. Had the father lived beyond Karl's early youth,

he would doubtless have been greatly pained by the radicalism of

his gifted son, as well as by his personal privations. But the

mother lived until 1863, while Karl was everywhere stirring the

fires of revolution, driven from land to land, both feared and

persecuted, and often half famished. As Mr. Spargo says:

It was the irony of life that the son, who kindled a mighty hope

in the hearts of unnumbered thousands of his fellow human beings,

a hope that is today inspiring millions of those who speak his

name with reverence and love, should be able to do that only by

destroying his mother's hope and happiness in her son, and that

every step he took should fill her heart with a great agony.

When young Marx grew out of boyhood into youth, he was attractive

to all those who met him. Tall, lithe, and graceful, he was so

extremely dark that his intimates called him "der neger"--"the

negro." His loosely tossing hair gave to him a still more exotic

appearance; but his eyes were true and frank, his nose denoted

strength and character, and his mouth was full of kindliness in

its expression. His lineaments were not those of the Jewish type.

Very late in life--he died in 1883--his hair and beard turned

white, but to the last his great mustache was drawn like a bar

across his face, remaining still as black as ink, and making his

appearance very striking. He was full of fun and gaiety. As was

only natural, there soon came into his life some one who learned

to love him, and to whom, in his turn, he gave a deep and unbroken


There had come to Treves--which passed from France to Prussia with

the downfall of Napoleon--a Prussian nobleman, the Baron Ludwig

von Westphalen, holding the official title of "national adviser."

The baron was of Scottish extraction on his mother's side, being

connected with the ducal family of Argyll. He was a man of genuine

rank, and might have shown all the arrogance and superciliousness

of the average Prussian official; but when he became associated

with Heinrich Marx he evinced none of that condescending manner.

The two men became firm friends, and the baron treated the

provincial lawyer as an equal.

The two families were on friendly terms. Von Westphalen's infant

daughter, who had the formidable name of Johanna Bertha Julie

Jenny von Westphalen, but who was usually spoken of as Jenny,

became, in time, an intimate of Sophie Marx. She was four years

older than Karl, but the two grew up together--he a high-spirited,

manly boy, and she a lovely and romantic girl.

The baron treated Karl as if the lad were a child of his own. He

influenced him to love romantic literature and poetry by

interpreting to him the great masterpieces, from Homer and

Shakespeare to Goethe and Lessing. He made a special study of

Dante, whose mysticism appealed to his somewhat dreamy nature, and

to the religious instinct that always lived in him, in spite of

his dislike for creeds and churches.

The lore that he imbibed in early childhood stood Karl in good

stead when he began his school life, and his preparation for the

university. He had an absolute genius for study, and was no less

fond of the sports and games of his companions, so that he seemed

to be marked out for success. At sixteen years of age he showed a

precocious ability for planning and carrying out his work with

thoroughness. His mind was evidently a creative mind, one that was

able to think out difficult problems without fatigue. His taste

was shown in his fondness for the classics, in studying which he

noted subtle distinctions of meaning that usually escape even the

mature scholar. Penetration, thoroughness, creativeness, and a

capacity for labor were the boy's chief characteristics.

With such gifts, and such a nature, he left home for the

university of Bonn. Here he disappointed all his friends. His

studies were neglected; he was morose, restless, and dissatisfied.

He fell into a number of scrapes, and ran into debt through sundry

small extravagances. All the reports that reached his home were

most unsatisfactory. What had come over the boy who had worked so

hard in the gymnasium at Treves?

The simple fact was that he had became love-sick. His separation

from Jenny von Westphalen had made him conscious of a feeling

which he had long entertained without knowing it. They had been

close companions. He had looked into her beautiful face and seen

the luminous response of her lovely eyes, but its meaning had not

flashed upon his mind. He was not old enough to have a great

consuming passion, he was merely conscious of her charm. As he

could see her every day, he did not realize how much he wanted

her, and how much a separation from her would mean.

As "absence makes the heart grow fonder," so it may suddenly draw

aside the veil behind which the truth is hidden. At Bonn young

Marx felt as if a blaze of light had flashed before him; and from

that moment his studies, his companions, and the ambitions that he

had hitherto cherished all seemed flat and stale. At night and in

the daytime there was just one thing which filled his mind and

heart--the beautiful vision of Jenny von Westphalen.

Meanwhile his family, and especially his father, had become

anxious at the reports which reached them. Karl was sent for, and

his stay at Bonn was ended.

Now that he was once more in the presence of the girl who charmed

him so, he recovered all his old-time spirits. He wooed her

ardently, and though she was more coy, now that she saw his

passion, she did not discourage him, but merely prolonged the

ecstasy of this wonderful love-making. As he pressed her more and

more, and no one guessed the story, there came a time when she was

urged to let herself become engaged to him.

Here was seen the difference in their ages--a difference that had

an effect upon their future. It means much that a girl should be

four years older than the man who seeks her hand. She is four

years wiser; and a girl of twenty is, in fact, a match for a youth

of twenty-five. Brought up as she had been, in an aristocratic

home, with the blood of two noble families in her veins, and being

wont to hear the easy and somewhat cynical talk of worldly people,

she knew better than poor Karl the un-wisdom of what she was about

to do.

She was noble, the daughter of one high official and the sister of

another. Those whom she knew were persons of rank and station. On

the other hand, young Marx, though he had accepted Christianity,

was the son of a provincial Jewish lawyer, with no fortune, and

with a bad record at the university. When she thought of all these

things, she may well have hesitated; but the earnest pleading and

intense ardor of Karl Marx broke down all barriers between them,

and they became engaged, without informing Jenny's father of their

compact. Then they parted for a while, and Karl returned to his

home, filled with romantic thoughts.

He was also full of ambition and of desire for achievement. He had

won the loveliest girl in Treves, and now he must go forth into

the world and conquer it for her sake. He begged his father to

send him to Berlin, and showed how much more advantageous was that

new and splendid university, where Hegel's fame was still in the


In answer to his father's questions, the younger Marx replied:

"I have something to tell you that will explain all; but first you

must give me your word that you will tell no one."

"I trust you wholly," said the father. "I will not reveal what you

may say to me."

"Well," returned the son, "I am engaged to marry Jenny von

Westphalen. She wishes it kept a secret from her father, but I am

at liberty to tell you of it."

The elder Marx was at once shocked and seriously disturbed. Baron

von Westphalen was his old and intimate friend. No thought of

romance between their children had ever come into his mind. It

seemed disloyal to keep the verlobung of Karl and Jenny a secret;

for should it be revealed, what would the baron think of Marx?

Their disparity of rank and fortune would make the whole affair

stand out as something wrong and underhand.

The father endeavored to make his son see all this. He begged him

to go and tell the baron, but young Marx was not to be persuaded.

"Send me to Berlin," he said, "and we shall again be separated;

but I shall work and make a name for myself, so that when I return

neither Jenny nor her father will have occasion to be disturbed by

our engagement."

With these words he half satisfied his father, and before long he

was sent to Berlin, where he fell manfully upon his studies. His

father had insisted that he should study law; but his own tastes

were for philosophy and history. He attended lectures in

jurisprudence "as a necessary evil," but he read omnivorously in

subjects that were nearer to his heart. The result was that his

official record was not much better than it had been at Bonn.

The same sort of restlessness, too, took possession of him when he

found that Jenny would not answer his letters. No matter how

eagerly and tenderly he wrote to her, there came no reply. Even

the most passionate pleadings left her silent and unresponsive.

Karl could not complain, for she had warned him that she would not

write to him. She felt that their engagement, being secret, was

anomalous, and that until her family knew of it she was not free

to act as she might wish.

Here again was seen the wisdom of her maturer years; but Karl

could not be equally reasonable. He showered her with letters,

which still she would not answer. He wrote to his father in words

of fire. At last, driven to despair, he said that he was going to

write to the Baron von Westphalen, reveal the secret, and ask for

the baron's fatherly consent.

It seemed a reckless thing to do, and yet it turned out to be the

wisest. The baron knew that such an engagement meant a social

sacrifice, and that, apart from the matter of rank, young Marx was

without any fortune to give the girl the luxuries to which she had

been accustomed. Other and more eligible suitors were always

within view. But here Jenny herself spoke out more strongly than

she had ever done to Karl. She was willing to accept him with what

he was able to give her. She cared nothing for any other man, and

she begged her father to make both of them completely happy.

Thus it seemed that all was well, yet for some reason or other

Jenny would not write to Karl, and once more he was almost driven

to distraction. He wrote bitter letters to his father, who tried

to comfort him. The baron himself sent messages of friendly

advice, but what young man in his teens was ever reasonable? So

violent was Karl that at last his father wrote to him:

I am disgusted with your letters. Their unreasonable tone is

loathsome to me. I should never had expected it of you. Haven't

you been lucky from your cradle up?

Finally Karl received one letter from his betrothed--a letter that

transfused him with ecstatic joy for about a day, and then sent

him back to his old unrest. This, however, may be taken as a part

of Marx's curious nature, which was never satisfied, but was

always reaching after something which could not be had.

He fell to writing poetry, of which he sent three volumes to

Jenny--which must have been rather trying to her, since the verse

was very poor. He studied the higher mathematics, English and

Italian, some Latin, and a miscellaneous collection of works on

history and literature. But poetry almost turned his mind. In

later years he wrote:

Everything was centered on poetry, as if I were bewitched by some

uncanny power.

Luckily, he was wise enough, after a time, to recognize how

halting were his poems when compared with those of the great

masters; and so he resumed his restless, desultory work. He still

sent his father letters that were like wild cries. They evoked, in

reply, a very natural burst of anger:

Complete disorder, silly wandering through all branches of

science, silly brooding at the burning oil-lamp! In your wildness

you see with four eyes--a horrible setback and disregard for

everything decent. And in the pursuit of this senseless and

purposeless learning you think to raise the fruits which are to

unite you with your beloved one! What harvest do you expect to

gather from them which will enable you to fulfil your duty toward


Writing to him again, his father speaks of something that Karl had

written as "a mad composition, which denotes clearly how you waste

your ability and spend nights in order to create such

monstrosities." The young man was even forbidden to return home

for the Easter holidays. This meant giving up the sight of Jenny,

whom he had not seen for a whole year. But fortune arranged it

otherwise; for not many weeks later death removed the parent who

had loved him and whom he had loved, though neither of them could

understand the other. The father represented the old order of

things; the son was born to discontent and to look forward to a

new heaven and a new earth.

Returning to Berlin, Karl resumed his studies; but as before, they

were very desultory in their character, and began to run upon

social questions, which were indeed setting Germany into a

ferment. He took his degree, and thought of becoming an instructor

at the university of Jena; but his radicalism prevented this, and

he became the editor of a liberal newspaper, which soon, however,

became so very radical as to lead to his withdrawal.

It now seemed best that Marx should seek other fields of activity.

To remain in Germany was dangerous to himself and discreditable to

Jenny's relatives, with their status as Prussian officials. In the

summer of 1843, he went forth into the world--at last an

"international." Jenny, who had grown to believe in him as against

her own family, asked for nothing better than to wander with him,

if only they might be married. And they were married in this same

summer, and spent a short honeymoon at Bingen on the Rhine--made

famous by Mrs. Norton's poem. It was the brief glimpse of sunshine

that was to precede year after year of anxiety and want.

Leaving Germany, Marx and Jenny went to Paris, where he became

known to some of the intellectual lights of the French capital,

such as Bakunin, the great Russian anarchist, Proudhon, Cabet, and

Saint-Simon. Most important of all was his intimacy with the poet

Heine, that marvelous creature whose fascination took on a

thousand forms, and whom no one could approach without feeling his

strange allurement.

Since Goethe's death, down to the present time, there has been no

figure in German literature comparable to Heine. His prose was

exquisite. His poetry ran through the whole gamut of humanity and

of the sensations that come to us from the outer world. In his

poems are sweet melodies and passionate cries of revolt, stirring

ballads of the sea and tender love-songs--strange as these last

seem when coming from this cynic.

For cynic he was, deep down in his heart, though his face, when in

repose, was like the conventional pictures of Christ. His

fascinations destroyed the peace of many a woman; and it was only

after many years of self-indulgence that he married the faithful

Mathilde Mirat in what he termed a "conscience marriage." Soon

after he went to his "mattress-grave," as he called it, a hopeless


To Heine came Marx and his beautiful bride. One may speculate as

to Jenny's estimate of her husband. Since his boyhood, she had not

seen him very much. At that time he was a merry, light-hearted

youth, a jovial comrade, and one of whom any girl would be proud.

But since his long stay in Berlin, and his absorption in the

theories of men like Engels and Bauer, he had become a very

different sort of man, at least to her.

Groping, lost in brown studies, dreamy, at times morose, he was by

no means a sympathetic and congenial husband for a high-bred,

spirited girl, such as Jenny von Westphalen. His natural drift was

toward a beer-garden, a group of frowsy followers, the reek of

vile tobacco, and the smell of sour beer. One cannot but think

that his beautiful wife must have been repelled by this, though

with her constant nature she still loved him.

In Heinrich Heine she found a spirit that seemed akin to hers. Mr.

Spargo says--and in what he says one must read a great deal

between the lines:

The admiration of Jenny Marx for the poet was even more ardent

than that of her husband. He fascinated her because, as she said,

he was "so modern," while Heine was drawn to her because she was

"so sympathetic."

It must be that Heine held the heart of this beautiful woman in

his hand. He knew so well the art of fascination; he knew just how

to supply the void which Marx had left. The two were indeed

affinities in heart and soul; yet for once the cynical poet stayed

his hand, and said no word that would have been disloyal to his

friend. Jenny loved him with a love that might have blazed into a

lasting flame; but fortunately there appeared a special providence

to save her from herself. The French government, at the request of

the King of Prussia, banished Marx from its dominions; and from

that day until he had become an old man he was a wanderer and an

exile, with few friends and little money, sustained by nothing but

Jenny's fidelity and by his infinite faith in a cause that crushed

him to the earth.

There is a curious parallel between the life of Marx and that of

Richard Wagner down to the time when the latter discovered a royal

patron. Both of them were hounded from country to country; both of

them worked laboriously for so scanty a living as to verge, at

times, upon starvation. Both of them were victims to a cause in

which they earnestly believed--an economic cause in the one case,

an artistic cause in the other. Wagner's triumph came before his

death, and the world has accepted his theory of the music-drama.

The cause of Marx is far greater and more tremendous, because it

strikes at the base of human life and social well-being.

The clash between Wagner and his critics was a matter of poetry

and dramatic music. It was not vital to the human race. The cause

of Marx is one that is only now beginning to be understood and

recognized by millions of men and women in all the countries of

the earth. In his lifetime he issued a manifesto that has become a

classic among economists. He organized the great International

Association of Workmen, which set all Europe in a blaze and

extended even to America. His great book, "Capital"--Das Kapital--

which was not completed until the last years of his life, is read

to-day by thousands as an almost sacred work.

Like Wagner and his Minna, the wife of Marx's youth clung to him

through his utmost vicissitudes, denying herself the necessities

of life so that he might not starve. In London, where he spent his

latest days, he was secure from danger, yet still a sort of

persecution seemed to follow him. For some time, nothing that he

wrote could find a printer. Wherever he went, people looked at him

askance. He and his six children lived upon the sum of five

dollars a week, which was paid him by the New York Tribune,

through the influence of the late Charles A. Dana. When his last

child was born, and the mother's life was in serious danger, Marx

complained that there was no cradle for the baby, and a little

later that there was no coffin for its burial.

Marx had ceased to believe in marriage, despised the church, and

cared nothing for government. Yet, unlike Wagner, he was true to

the woman who had given up so much for him. He never sank to an

artistic degeneracy. Though he rejected creeds, he was

nevertheless a man of genuine religious feeling. Though he

believed all present government to be an evil, he hoped to make it

better, or rather he hoped to substitute for it a system by which

all men might get an equal share of what it is right and just for

them to have.

Such was Marx, and thus he lived and died. His wife, who had long

been cut off from her relatives, died about a year before him.

When she was buried, he stumbled and fell into her grave, and from

that time until his own death he had no further interest in life.

He had been faithful to a woman and to a cause. That cause was so

tremendous as to overwhelm him. In sixty years only the first

great stirrings of it could be felt. Its teachings may end in

nothing, but only a century or more of effort and of earnest

striving can make it plain whether Karl Marx was a world-mover or

a martyr to a cause that was destined to be lost.